Download Beyond Positivism and Relativism: Theory, Method, and by Larry Laudan PDF

By Larry Laudan

With the decline of logical positivism after 1950, a lot paintings within the philosophy of technological know-how has careened towards an uncritical relativistic technique. Many students, confronted with a call among a narrowly restrictive positivism and an “anything is going” relativism, have sought to discover a center direction within the debate.In this choice of papers, a number of of which look right here for the 1st time, Larry Laudan argues that resolving this hassle contains now not a few centrist compromise place yet particularly a perception of clinical wisdom that is going past either positivism and relativism. This perception needs to start with the rejection of assumptions approximately wisdom that those it seems that antagonistic positions carry in universal. Relativism, for Laudan, is a very self-defeating type of neopositivism.In displaying the connections among those methods and clarifying the positions of such influential philosophers as Thomas Kuhn and Paul Feyerabend, Laudan does the nice provider of laying the basis for an account of technology that rejects the error of positivism with no delivering relief and luxury to the enemies of cause. He additionally takes a clean examine many different crucial problems with clinical philosophy, together with the science/non-science demarcation, the underdetermination of idea through proof, and the contested position of social components within the legitimation of clinical knowledge.Beyond Positivism and Relativism is a huge assertion concerning the nature of technology and facts that may command the curiosity of philosophers of technological know-how, epistemologists, sociologists of information, and all who're heavily all for technological know-how, clinical growth, and the results for wisdom in lots of different fields.

Show description

Read Online or Download Beyond Positivism and Relativism: Theory, Method, and Evidence PDF

Best history & philosophy books

Philosophy, Science and Divine Action

Some of the most vital and arguable topics within the modern discussion between scientists and Christian theologians is the difficulty of "divine motion" on the planet. This quantity brings jointly contributions from major students in this subject, which emerged out of the medical views on Divine motion undertaking, co-sponsored by means of the Vatican Observatory and the guts for Theology and normal technology.

Concepts of Force

Either historic remedy and significant research, this paintings by way of a famous physicist takes a desirable examine a primary of physics, tracing its improvement from historic to fashionable occasions. Kepler's initiation of medical conceptualization, Newton's definition, post-Newtonian reinterpretation — contrasting ideas of Leibniz, Boscovich, Kant with these of Mach, Kirchhoff, Hertz.

The aspiring adept : Robert Boyle and his alchemical quest

The Aspiring Adept offers a provocative new view of Robert Boyle (1627-1691), one of many top figures of the medical Revolution, by means of revealing for the 1st time his avid and lifetime pursuit of alchemy. Boyle has usually been thought of, besides Newton, a founding father of smooth technological know-how due to his mechanical philosophy and his experimentation with the air-pump and different early medical gear.

Extra resources for Beyond Positivism and Relativism: Theory, Method, and Evidence

Sample text

All of which is to say that showing that rival theories enjoy the same 'empirical support'--in any sense of that term countenanced by (2 )--requires more than those rivals are compatible with, or capable of entailing, the same 'supporting' evidence. (2 ) turns out centrally to be a claim in the theory of evidence and, since Quine does not address the evidence relation in "Two Dogmas . ," one will not find further clarification of this issue there. 27 Of course, " Two Dogmas . " was not Quine's last effort to grapple with these issues.

On Quine's view, the only considerations which we could possibly invoke to block such stratagems have to do with pragmatic, not epistemic, rationality. 16 ) Thus far, the argument for ampliative underdetermination seems made of pretty trifling stuff. But there is a fourth, and decidedly nontrivial, stratagem which Quine envisages for showing how our Popperian principle underdetermines theory choice. This is the one which has received virtually all the exegetical attention; quite rightly, too, since Quine's arguments on the other three are transparently question-begging because they fail to establish the rationality of holding onto any theory in the face of any evidence.

34 In sum, Quine fails to show that theory choice is ampliatively underdetermined even by existing codifications of scientific methodology (an of which go considerably beyond the principle of simplicity), let alone by all possible such codifications. 35 More importantly for our purposes, even if Quine were right that no ideal organon of methodology could ever pick out any theory as uniquely satisfying its demands, we should note--in the version of underdetermination contained in the last passage from Quine--how drastically he has apparently weakened his claims from those of "Two Dogmas.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.23 of 5 – based on 40 votes